Tony's Pizza

Tony’s Pizza stands as a testament to authentic pizza craftsmanship and enduring culinary tradition in San Marino, California. Located at 2555 Huntington Dr, San Marino, CA 91108, this establishment has become a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts seeking genuine New York-style pizzas prepared with care and dedication. Operating as a no-frills counter-serve joint, Tony’s Pizza embodies the philosophy that exceptional food doesn’t require pretense or elaborate presentation—just quality ingredients, time-honored techniques, and a passion for satisfying customers.

The restaurant’s commitment to authenticity traces back to its founding in 1973, when it first opened its doors to the San Marino community. What began as a neighborhood pizzeria has evolved into a respected establishment known for maintaining an old secret recipe that continues to delight patrons decades later. This longevity speaks volumes about the consistency and quality that Tony’s Pizza delivers with every order. The pizza-making process at Tony’s reflects a deep respect for traditional methods, combining crispy, crunchy crusts with carefully selected toppings and sauce made from quality ingredients that honor the pizza-making heritage.

Beyond its signature pizzas, Tony’s Pizza offers a diverse menu that caters to various tastes and preferences. In addition to their renowned New York-style pizzas, the restaurant serves an array of sandwiches and pasta dishes, providing customers with multiple options for a satisfying meal. This menu diversity ensures that whether you’re a devoted pizza lover or someone seeking alternative Italian fare, Tony’s Pizza has something to offer. The counter-serve format keeps operations efficient and straightforward, allowing customers to place orders quickly and receive their food promptly without unnecessary complications.

The restaurant’s reputation has earned it recognition among local diners and travelers alike. On Tripadvisor, Tony’s Pizza maintains a solid 4.5 out of 5-star rating and ranks as the #5 restaurant in San Marino, reflecting consistent positive feedback from satisfied customers. Reviews frequently highlight the quality of the pizza and the value offered, with patrons describing it as “the best pizza west of NY,” a compliment that underscores how seriously the establishment takes its craft. The well-organized website and efficient ordering system make it convenient for customers to place takeout orders, and the restaurant’s commitment to timeliness ensures that orders are ready as promised.

Operating with extended hours throughout the week, Tony’s Pizza accommodates both lunch and dinner service, opening at 11:00 AM and remaining open until 8:00 PM from Wednesday through Saturday. This schedule makes the restaurant accessible for various dining occasions, whether customers are looking for a quick lunch break or an evening meal. The wheelchair-accessible location demonstrates the restaurant’s commitment to serving the entire community inclusively.

For those seeking authentic New York-style pizza in the San Marino area, Tony’s Pizza represents a reliable choice backed by over fifty years of experience and dedication to quality. The combination of traditional recipes, quality ingredients, diverse menu options, and consistent service has established Tony’s Pizza as a cornerstone of the local dining scene. Whether ordering for personal enjoyment, family gatherings, or special events, customers can reach Tony’s Pizza at +1 626-793-4114 to place their orders and experience the pizza-making excellence that has defined this establishment since 1973.