🍕 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fort Myers, Florida
34 pizza restaurants in Fort Myers, Florida, ranked by Google rating and number of reviews. Featured listings appear first.
Locally owned neighborhood pizzeria and craft beer bar in Downtown Fort Myers, making New York style pizza from hand-tossed dough. Watch our pizza makers in our big front window. We offer a full menu of specialty pizzas,…
Welcome to Tony's NY Pizza, proudly serving Fort Myers with authentic New York-style pizza and classic Italian cuisine. As a family-owned pizzeria, we are dedicated to bringing the true taste of New York to Southwest Flo…
Two-time national champion for Best Non-Traditional Pizza — winner of the Caputo Cup — Fine Folk Pizza has been serving Fort Myers hand-crafted, artisan pizza since 2015. Full vegan and gluten-free menus, over 40 specia…
Old school pizza shop
McGregor Pizza & Deli is locally-owned and operated by Katie Madden Marciano, a Fort Myers native who grew up right down the street at Hibiscus Drive. As a child, Katie loved riding her bike to what was once called, “Lit…
Welcome to Lombardough’s ! We’re not just pizza, pasta, hamburgers, wing and subs makers, we’re artists painting deliciousness on every dish at our funky-artistic dining and outdoor patio. Our secret? A nifty brick oven …
Welcome to Coozy Pizza! Located in Fort Myers, we are your go-to spot for incredibly fresh, hot, and delicious artisan pizza. We make our pizza daily in a stone oven with high-quality ingredients, offering fast takeout a…
Citrola's on College has been serving authentic Italian cuisine in SWFL for over 20 years! What makes us so good? We don't use gimmicks to earn your business. For 20 years we have been winning the stomachs of thousands o…
Experience a taste of Italy at Amantia Wood Fire Pizzeria, where authentic Italian cuisine comes to life. Since opening its doors in 2026, this inviting restaurant has been serving up the true spirit of traditional pizza…
Italian restaurant and pizzeria
take out / dine in - small locally owned, family business. Dine in seating is very limited & on a first come, first serve basis. Parties larger than 4 should call for accommodations. FRESH, never frozen ingredients. Kind…
Serving real New York pie since 1998
For authentic Italian pizza, pasta and more Pizza Pub Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria should be your only choice! We offer a wide selection of pasta, salads and hand-tossed pizza made with fresh quality ingredients! $10 Mi…
Family-owned Italian restaurant and pizzeria in South Fort Myers, FL, on US 41. Serving authentic New York Italian recipes since 1979 — pizza, pasta, seafood, and classic Italian-American specialties. Dine-in, takeout, a…
Since 2003, Blue Moon Pizza has been serving up authentic specialty and made-to-order pizzas made perfect because we couple flavors with high quality, fresh ingredients. We have four locations in the Atlanta metro area a…
Fat Tony’s Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria in Fort Myers serving quality, handcrafted pies made fresh every day. We focus on simple ingredients, consistent flavor, and pizzas baked in traditional deck ovens for that per…
Authentic Coal Fired Pizza so good, it should be Illegal.
Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers has been serving up fresh, stone-baked pizzas to order in an eclectic, art-filled, and family-friendly environment. Each Mellow is locally owned and operated and provides a unique feel focuse…
pizzeria in fort myers and Lehigh
Exceptional quality at lightning fast speed is what we're all about. Artisanal ingredients on the assembly line. Inventive to classic. You decide from over 30+ toppings. Blazing hot oven + dedicated pizzasmith + 180 seco…
Pizza Restaurants in nearby areas
Other categories in Fort Myers
Frequently asked questions
How many pizza restaurants are there in Fort Myers, Florida?
The directory currently lists 34 pizza restaurants in Fort Myers, Florida, updated continuously from Google Maps.
Which pizza restaurant in Fort Myers, Florida is rated highest?
Weighing rating against review count, Downtown House of Pizza currently leads with 4.7 out of 5 from 5,449 reviews.
How is this list ranked?
Featured listings (paid, always labeled) come first; the rest are ordered by a score that balances the average Google rating against the number of reviews, so a 4.8 from 300 reviews outranks a 5.0 from 2.
Can I call these pizza restaurants directly?
Yes. 20 of the 20 listings on this page show a phone number; tap the call button on each card.
What else does Fort Myers, Florida have besides pizza restaurants?
Other well-covered categories in Fort Myers, Florida include Pizza Restaurants, Italian Restaurants, Restaurants, Pizza Buffets; see “Other categories” below.
My business is missing, how do I add it?
Use the “Add a business” page (free, reviewed within days). If it is already listed, open its page and choose “Claim this listing”.
Missing a pizza place? Add it free. Own one of these? Get featured at the top.