🍕 Best Pizza Restaurants in Pensacola, Florida
27 pizza restaurants in Pensacola, Florida, ranked by Google rating and number of reviews. Featured listings appear first.
Located at 3001 E Cervantes St, Pensacola, FL 32503, New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria operates as a pizza restaurant serving Pensacola in Florida.
Sky's Pizza Pie is a pizza restaurant in Pensacola, Florida.
The Tuscan Oven Pizzeria is one of the pizza restaurants listed in Pensacola, Florida.
O'Zone Pizza Pub is a pizza restaurant in Pensacola, Florida.
Voted Best Pizza in Pensacola by VIP Magazine 2020, 2021, 2022 & 2024! Locally owned pizza restaurant where we make pizza dough, sauces and dressings daily. Fresh ingredients! Homemade pizza dough, sauces and dressings. …
New York style pizza locally owned & inspired by the vibrant community of Pensacola. Our pizza dough is made from scratch whether it’s an individual slice or entire 20” pie. You can customize any pizza to fit your own un…
Lucky Dough Pizza, recognized by 50 Top Pizza USA 2026, specializes in crafting naturally leavened (sourdough), authentic Napoletana-style pizzas baked in traditional wood-fired ovens. We use organic produce, all-natural…
Lillian's now has live music and Daiquiri Bar on the new back deck.
Family owned and operated pizza shop serving New York style pizza both large 18” and small 14”. Call ahead, pre-order, take out. Try a classic or have us make a custom job. Cauliflower crust also available in 14”.
Georgio’s has been in business for over 35 years, and certainly not by accident! Thanks to our fresh dough, homemade sauce, and dedication to freshness, we’re known for having the best pizza on the coast. But pizza’s not…
At Lost Pizza Co. we want your dining experience to be as fun as getting to go see the bearded lady, riding a camel while swallowing a sword at the state fair when you were 10 years old (yeah it’s that cool!) We make eve…
Serving authentic New York-style and Sicilian pizzas since 1947, Papa's Pizza offers handcrafted pies, calzones, strombolis, and pasta dishes made with fresh, daily-prepared dough and sauces.
Mellow Mushroom Pizza Bakers has been serving up fresh, stone-baked pizzas to order in an eclectic, art-filled, and family-friendly environment. Each Mellow is locally owned and operated and provides a unique feel focuse…
Our Food Safety and quality are our top priorities in the products we serve you. Dough – made fresh from scratch every single day using only the best ingredients Sauces – made fresh daily using our secret recipes Veggie…
Established in 2020. We saw the need for REAL Neapolitan Pizza in a sea of "cookiecutter" pizza shops in our area. Our pizza making is an art and our methods are the same as those cultivated and refined over 200 years i…
Santino's Pizza & Grinders is one of the pizza restaurants listed in Pensacola, Florida.
At BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse, we've been serving up a one-of-a-kind Brewhouse experience for over forty years. We pride ourselves in our craft and attention to detail. Our innovative and broad menu features a Californi…
Northwest Pensacola's best freshly made pizzas!
Marco's Pizza Pensacola makes pizza the authentic Italian way, with dough made fresh in-store every day, a special three-cheese blend, and a sauce recipe that hasn't changed since our founding in 1978.
🍕✨ Anthony’s Pizza Cone ✨🍕 Somos un restaurante familiar nacido del amor por la pizza y de una idea tan especial como nuestro bebé Anthony 💙, quien nos inspiró a crear algo diferente. Aquí reinventamos la pizza en una fo…
Pizza Restaurants in nearby areas
Other categories in Pensacola
Frequently asked questions
How many pizza restaurants are there in Pensacola, Florida?
The directory currently lists 27 pizza restaurants in Pensacola, Florida, updated continuously from Google Maps.
Which pizza restaurant in Pensacola, Florida is rated highest?
Weighing rating against review count, New Yorker Deli & Pizzeria currently leads with 4.7 out of 5 from 1,979 reviews.
How is this list ranked?
Featured listings (paid, always labeled) come first; the rest are ordered by a score that balances the average Google rating against the number of reviews, so a 4.8 from 300 reviews outranks a 5.0 from 2.
Can I call these pizza restaurants directly?
Yes. 19 of the 20 listings on this page show a phone number; tap the call button on each card.
What else does Pensacola, Florida have besides pizza restaurants?
Other well-covered categories in Pensacola, Florida include Pizza Restaurants, Restaurants, Italian Restaurants, Caterers; see “Other categories” below.
My business is missing, how do I add it?
Use the “Add a business” page (free, reviewed within days). If it is already listed, open its page and choose “Claim this listing”.
Missing a pizza place? Add it free. Own one of these? Get featured at the top.